My name is Chuck Beatty. I was a course
sup at Flag in 1977 or 78 when you were
FSO public and possibly getting some ordered auditing or paid Flag auditing, not sure
Me and the black supervisor, my boss, Al
Baker, supervised you for a short time,
inbetween your sessions (if you were
getting sessions, think so, but not
You were the ex-Sea Org officer and then
Flag public, hanging out between sessions
on some sort of auditing you were getting
at that time, is what I recall. This must
have been 77, 10th floor ballroom, you sat
facing the back stairway to the 11th floor,
you sat near the center walkway down the
ballroom floor, you had your white bush
shorts and short sleaves white bush jacket
on. You were blabbing about some auditing
wins one moment, and gave me the excuse
you couldn't study or concentrate, and
were chuckling a lot (were you getting an
L at that time?).
I thank you for the above general advice,
glad you been/there---done/that on about
everything written in the tech vols, etc.
I respect anyone who has NOT been
silenced by Hubbard's worst directive
rules that have so harmfully effected
and still harm several generations we
both agree I think.
I respect all former Sea Org and
Scientologists who rose above the rules
and now speak out, saying whatever the
hell they wish.
You're in a whole different league of
Scientology movement participant. I
am happy to be able to talk with you.
While I don't support any "tech", I do
respect the kindness and decency of ANY
human being trying to help another out,
and I am sure you personally would not be succeding unless you personally genuinely
as a person wished well for others.
I think it all comes down to what people
wish for their fellows, and actually
doing something helpful.
Being a longtime staffer (1975-2003) in
the Sea Org, having met you briefly as
your supervisor, and then having as a
Flag staffer in the years after 81,
heard all the black PR material spread
on you for decades thereafter, and having
myself spread my own black PR on you, for
which I am sorry and wish to directly now
apologize to you for. I just wanted to
communicate and thank you for being a
part of the Hubbard Scientology history,
sharing your views and having the integrity
to not be silenced by Hubbard's worst
opinions turned into the harmfully
recoiling policies the official church is
saddled with today.
I've heard good things about you from kind-
hearted Free Zone people who I got no beef
I got no beef with anyone who acts decently
and in general treats their fellow man well.
I think the basic good characteristics
mankind out in the regular world has
agreed upon are good, I think those
"stable data" undercut Hubbard's works.
People need to get out, see the world has
better ideas and I think people have the
goddamn right to speak their minds about
anything they wish.
Better to fumble around and learn oneself,
even if it means making an occasional
fool of oneself by spouting dumb ideas
oneself, rather than sink into the
complacent role of a movement member who
just adopts one man's ideas without
question, especially when one swallows
untold amounts of seriously wrong
principles out of step with humanity's
been/there--done/that far wiser wisdom.
Hubbard's world, once entered, eliminates
due to LRH's voluminous preemptive
writings, wiser human principles that
Hubbard failed to see.
Decency, honesty, operating reasonably
(not the 1984 Hubbard redefinition of
"reasonable" but the regular world
respected connotation), are
senior, in my opinion, to the all-
consuming detailed activities Hubbard
got his faithful to buy into to the
exclusion of these aobve principles.
Hubbard is the ultimate who, it isn't just
DM, but DM has been one nasty bad influence
tanking the movement more than Hubbard.
But it's Hubbard's worst ideas and LRH's
own personal Sea Org heavy ethics
behavior that serves as DM's justification
for DM's own disgraceful behavior.
St. Pete Times said this is so many words.
The intelligent people in the world know
what is going on.
Glad I have been able to speak to you here.
Glad this whole platform exists for former
members to come out, and exchange their
Chuck Beatty 412-260-1170
"Our bombastic lapidary style is good only for inflating dwarfs." Jean-Jacques Rousseau (from "Emile, or On Education")